2014:

                Mo Felt- Dickinson College

                Nick Naumann- West Liberty University

                Trevor Stewart- West Liberty University

                Russel Schwartzfeger- Potomac State/ USC Upstate

                Andrew Kowalo- Potomac State/ Liberty University/ Washington Wildthings

2015:

                Michael Grove- West Virginia University              

                Mario Peroni- West Liberty University

                Nate Bakaitis- West Liberty University

                Jameson Murray- West Liberty University

2016:

                Colton Coss- Morehead State, Cuyahoga College, West Liberty University

                Matthew Gruber- West Liberty University

                Soup Campbell- West Liberty University

2017:

                Chad Harper- Potomac State/ West Liberty University

                Jub Delbrugge- West Liberty University

                Jarrett Delbrugge- West Liberty University

                Frank Favede- Dickinson College/ Wheeling Jesuit University

                Brian Shaw- Wheeling Jesuit University