2014:
Mo Felt- Dickinson College
Nick Naumann- West Liberty University
Trevor Stewart- West Liberty University
Russel Schwertfeger- Potomac State/ USC Upstate
Andrew Kowalo- Potomac State/ Liberty University/ Washington Wildthings
2015:
Michael Grove- West Virginia University
Mario Peroni- West Liberty University
Nate Bakaitis- West Liberty University
Jameson Murray- West Liberty University
2016:
Colton Coss- Morehead State, Cuyahoga College, West Liberty University
Matthew Gruber- West Liberty University
Brian '“Soup” Campbell- West Liberty University
2017:
Chad Harper- Potomac State/ West Liberty University
Justin “Jub” Delbrugge- West Liberty University
Jarrett Delbrugge- West Liberty University
Frank Favede- Dickinson College/ Wheeling Jesuit University
Brian Shaw- Wheeling Jesuit University
2018:
Isaac Rine- West Liberty University
Jacob “Butter” Murray- Wheeling Jesuit University
Ross Salvatori- West Liberty University
2019:
Trevor Thomas- Potomac State
Jarrod Jones- Fairmont State University
Logan Wells- Wheeling Jesuit/ West Liberty University
Dom Gorence- Muskingum University
Ryan Hummel- West Liberty University
Bryce Bauer- West Liberty University
Stephen Graebe- West Liberty University
2020:
Isaac Hines- West Liberty University
Erik Cover- Muskingum University
2021: James Salvatori- West Liberty University/ Cal Pa
2022: Zachary Taylor - Otterbein University
Dylan Gongola- Fairmont State University
Michael Toepfer- West Liberty
2023:
2024: Alex Taylor- Ohio University
Jack Selmon- Wheeling University (Injured)
Hunter Mueller- Christian Brothers University
Ethan Clark- WV Wesleyan (Injured)
